What’s in a name? Quite a bit…

Geir Magnusson: “What exactly is the result when the distros compile and package the OpenJDK source? I’ll argue it’s by definition not “JavaTM” (or “Java compatible”) because it hasn’t passed the TCK [the Technology Compatibility Kit, the Java compatibility test suite from Sun].”

Very good question. I agree with Geir—it shouldn’t be called Java unless it has passed the test suite. If it’s cost prohibitive to run the test suite against third party versions, that should be remedied now that the reference implementation is open source.

(Via James Governor.)

4 Responses to “What’s in a name? Quite a bit…”

  1. Tortanick Says:

    Sorry for going off topic, I just wanted to know how long I should expect after signup to the LSB packageing mailing list before I get a confermation E-mail?

  2. Ian Murdock Says:

    We’re having some trouble with the packaging mailing list. It should be working again shortly. -ian

  3. Tortanick Says:

    Tortanick, ok then. Do I need to resignup later?

  4. Ian Murdock Says:

    Will get back to you. -ian